Let’s step into our way-back machine, a time machine that I have made out of a cardboard box, and let’s turn the dial to “The West Wing“.
Everyone remembers this show, right? If you’re a liberal, then you particularly remember Bartlet as “the president we wish we had,” at least for the first four seasons (we won’t be remembering the last three seasons with quite so much fondness). Maybe some day I’ll write something on Barack Obama and whether he’s the true life Bartlet, but let’s leave that question to another day.
Here’s my question for today: What was your SINGLE FAVORITE EPISODE for the show? That’s right, just one episode.
Very very difficult for me to pick just one. Like many others, I have the DVD set for the first four seasons, and if I were to rank the seasons, I’d probably go (1) Season Two, (2) Season One, (3) Season Three, (4) Season Four. The reason I’d switch Season One and Two on my ranking – well, there are two: Moira Kelly and schmaltzy writing in spots. For example, and yes, it’s just the pilot, but Bartlet’s speech at the end “With the clothes on their back…” is a little cringe-worthy. There are others. And I think Moira Kelly was is was a good actress, but either the writing or her stress levels on the show let her down.
SO. One episode. Your favorite. Which one? Well, based on which episodes I have watched the most from the DVD set, there are three candidates for me:
1. In the Shadow of Two Gunmen, specifically Part Two. This was the two-part Season Two premiere, during which Josh recovers from being shot at Roslin.
2. Celestial Navigation, Season One, where Josh talks to the university about the administration’s efforts to nail down Justice Mendoza.
3. Noel, Season Two, where Josh works through his lingering issues with the gun shot during Christmas.
(Hmmmm… Looks like I like the Josh episodes? Didn’t think about that before.)
In the end, I have to go with In the Shadow, Part Two. Why? Something about seeing the Bartlet candidacy come together from absolutely nothing, or at least only a minor town hall-style meeting in New Hampshire with locals eating jello and chicken. Watching the staffers put together a winning primary strategy. Seeing how “What’s next?” was already woven into the fabric of the show by the writers, even by Episode 1 of Season 1 (wait until after Bartlet’s speech at the end). It all just worked for me.
What about for you? Which episode worked for you the best?